Adios to the Immigration Bill

Jun 28th, 2007 | By Michel Marizco | Category: General News, Immigration, Politics

Facebook

Twitter

Delicious

Stumble

Buzz

Digg

THE BORDER REPORT

Oh come on, did anybody really think the immigration bill would pass this time? Or last time, or the time before that?

According to this story, it’s a Red vs. Blue issue. The conservatives don’t want to give “amnesty” to the illegal immigrants, the liberals don’t think the bill gives the illegal immigrants enough safeguards.

I say nonsense. There’s no real interest in resolving immigration. The papers run the same, “Congress wrestles with immigration,” story four times a year on average.

Congress loves to pretend they control the memory-holes of information. Each time they run us through their circus, they pretend it’s the first time.

We faced the same complaints during the last session, and frankly we’ve had these two same exact arguments going back to 2004 when Republicans Jim Kolbe and John McCain introduced the guestworker plan.

The liberals were and are suspicious of all conservative ideas – even if it might be a good idea. The conservatives clutch at their collective chests, moaning that the guestworker plan is “amnesty” and we can’t reward criminals.

After the mid-term elections, the Democrats swore they’d pass an immigration bill with the help of the president. That failed too.

The simple truth of the matter is this: this border isn’t broken at all. It works precisely how the market needs it to work.

I was reading through the CIA’s Family Jewels reports last night and came across one intelligence analysis that stated 500,000 to 600,000 illegal immigrants come across the border every year. The thing was written in 1999. Eight years later, the U.S. Border Patrol’s manpower nearly doubled while the federal budgets for border security top $8 billion a year. You’d think there’d be less illegal immigrants coming in and you’d be sorely mistaken. (I’ll dig it up later today and post it online).

According to the Homeland Security Department’s own numbers, 500,000 illegal immigrants successfully cross the border every year. They gave out those numbers in 2005, seven years after the CIA. Therefore, no matter what’s been spent on “border security,” the same numbers keep popping up – half a million people a year.

So no, Pres. Bush was wrong when he said back in 2004 that “our borders are broken.” They’re working just fine.

Sure, a few hundred people die every year, Arizona wildlands get trashed and the Drug War has long been lost, those are irrelevancies, best not talked about. In the grand scheme, they’re unimportant.

Our Congress has been squabbling over an immigration bill for more than three years now; that equates to about 1.7 million more people who made it in under the radar.

It doesn’t matter who they are, Democrat or Republican, you can’t tell me the bosses don’t know these things.

– Michael Marizco

4 comments
Leave a comment »

Daniel R. Patterson June 28th, 2007 3:28 pm
Valuable commentary.
Rita D. June 28th, 2007 5:27 pm
Now I just roll my eyes every time I hear they are going to fix the border problem.

There is much money and many political careers to be made from leaving everything the way it is: a complete messâ€¦ or a corporate wet dream for Boeing and the other commercial defense contractors.

At least youâ€™re keeping it real. Thanks.
gboyd June 28th, 2007 9:50 pm
Now that this bill has been voted dead I am less focused on this government. I believe this government is not for any human endevours except to please the big money that runs them. This includes the President.

I have long thought and worked with immagrant people. I have seen their plights and frustrations. They were not illegal. I have a REAL prblems with illegal immigration, im sorry. No group of people should have the power that these people have. The only reason they have it is becuase this screwed up governmnet has given it to them. They WANT them to have it.
They want to them to over run all the minorities and the middle class in whole.
This governmnet wants cheap damn labor and the laws to go with it. Who the hell does not understand what is going on. Wake up, all of you, including you who are illegal in this country. You will NEVER get amnesty because this has been TRIED AND FAILED. You will just work here as an underclass and in fear of deportation. Now that this governmnet has “failed” you, the states will start inacting thier reforms in answer to this invasion of innocent and guilty alike. This is why this bill was wanted, ask any senator. They did not want the chaos that will surely come to follow now that this bill is DEAD. Gather your loved ones, your friends and your thoughts. You will need much courage becuase you are now for at least the next two years an underclass in a country that does not care.
John Praytor June 29th, 2007 12:51 pm
Okay, the hype and hoopla re. the “Grand Compromise” is over, for now.

May I suggest that, as an option to be considered, we review history and a successful program from the days of yore. Specifically, President Dwight Eisenhower, who faced a similar illegal immigration problem and decided to solve it (unique in today’s political climate, I know). Follow the link below, and read the references cited therein.

http://www.csmonitor.com/2006/0706/p09s01-coop.html

In our ‘politically correct” society we’ll have to change the program name, but the application would certainly work again.

JohnP